Back To FAQ Topics
Question concerning use of Manual-Locking Carabiners. What are your thoughts on the use of a Manual-locking carabiner as the connecting device between an SRL and an ancorage connector? I had written a “do not use” statement for these type devices in our local Safety Standard; however, I have several folks who do not agree and wanted me to take the statement out of the standard. It seems we have a few of these devices and supervision does not want to toss them.
Why would we make this compromise in a safety rule just because it may have some merit due to procedure, training or use? People forget to screw up tight; that is the problem so it needs to be automatic closure and locking as a general rule. I do not believe any manual screw locking is advisable in any planned safety application involving fall protection with a connector such as a carabiner or snaphook going forward. There will be big changes happening with the Z359.0-4 printing in June by ASSE and effective date October 15th. The biggest change is snaphook gates going from 220 lbs to 3600 lbs in all directions. Manual lock carabiners should be tested with 3600 lbs worst case and of course they will open with a few ounces of force if unscrewed in this worst case situation. Why would we make this compromise in a safety rule just because it may have some merit due to procedure, training or use? People forget to screw up tight; that is the problem so it needs to be automatic closure and locking as a general rule.
Is there a brief written description out there somewhere of the snap hook issue discussed previously at A10?
The A10.32 is the only standard in USA specifying 220 lbs gates which are bendable by fingers (large snap only; the small lanyard snaps have 220 lbs gates that bend in tree climbing lumberjack work (fliplines) due to rolling (cured by swivel hooks). ,p>Go on PENSAFE 2012 catalog (2011-9 version), www.pensafe.ca, to see these hooks e.g. 5870ANSI; 5386 is the bad one on page 11. There does not appear to be a problem yet with 3600 lbs gates (Z359.1-2007). The new standard Z359.12-2009 -is replacing the Z359.1 along with other component standards. This issue will be addressed in soon to be released 4th edition of Introduction to Fall Protection. Check this site for details.
Question concerning use of Manual-Locking Carabiners. What are your thoughts on the use of a Manual-locking carabiner as the connecting device between an SRL and an ancorage connector? I had written a “do not use” statement for these type devices in our local Safety Standard; however, I have several folks who do not agree and wanted me to take the statement out of the standard. It seems we have a few of these devices and supervision does not want to toss them.
Why would we make this compromise in a safety rule just because it may have some merit due to procedure, training or use? People forget to screw up tight; that is the problem so it needs to be automatic closure and locking as a general rule. I do not believe any manual screw locking is advisable in any planned safety application involving fall protection with a connector such as a carabiner or snaphook going forward. There will be big changes happening with the Z359.0-4 printing in June by ASSE and effective date October 15th. The biggest change is snaphook gates going from 220 lbs to 3600 lbs in all directions. Manual lock carabiners should be tested with 3600 lbs worst case and of course they will open with a few ounces of force if unscrewed in this worst case situation. Why would we make this compromise in a safety rule just because it may have some merit due to procedure, training or use? People forget to screw up tight; that is the problem so it needs to be automatic closure and locking as a general rule.
Is there a brief written description out there somewhere of the snap hook issue discussed previously at A10?
The A10.32 is the only standard in USA specifying 220 lbs gates which are bendable by fingers (large snap only; the small lanyard snaps have 220 lbs gates that bend in tree climbing lumberjack work (fliplines) due to rolling (cured by swivel hooks). ,p>Go on PENSAFE 2012 catalog (2011-9 version), www.pensafe.ca, to see these hooks e.g. 5870ANSI; 5386 is the bad one on page 11. There does not appear to be a problem yet with 3600 lbs gates (Z359.1-2007). The new standard Z359.12-2009 -is replacing the Z359.1 along with other component standards. This issue will be addressed in soon to be released 4th edition of Introduction to Fall Protection. Check this site for details.
